Volume 6 Preprint 10
Stress Corrosion Cracking Behaviour of Retrogressed and Reaged 1441 Al-Li-Cu-Mg-Zr Alloy
K. S. Ghosh, K. Das and U. K. Chatterjee
Keywords: Al-Li alloy, Retrogression and reaging, Stress corrosion cracking
Because you are not logged-in to the journal, it is now our policy to display a 'text-only' version of the preprint. This version is obtained by extracting the text from the PDF or HTML file, and it is not guaranteed that the text will be a true image of the text of the paper. The text-only version is intended to act as a reference for search engines when they index the site, and it is not designed to be read by humans!
If you wish to view the human-readable version of the preprint, then please Register (if you have not already done so) and Login. Registration is completely free.
Volume 6 Paper C014
Stress Corrosion Cracking Behaviour of Retrogressed and Reaged
1441 Al-Li-Cu-Mg-Zr Alloy
K. S. Ghosh1, K. Das2 and U. K. Chatterjee2
Department of Metallurgical Engineering, National Institute of Technology Warangal – 506 004, India. E-mail address: firstname.lastname@example.org
Department of Metallurgical and Materials Engineering, Indian Institute of
Technology– Kharagpur - 721302, India. E-mail address: email@example.com
The susceptibility to stress corrosion cracking (SCC) of 1441 Al-Li-Cu-Mg-Zr alloy
in the peak aged, over aged and four retrogression and reaged (RRA) tempers has
been studied by using slow strain rate technique (SSRT) and constant load technique
in 3.5% NaCl, 3.5% NaCl + 0.1M LiCl + 0.3% H2O2 and 3.5% NaCl + 0.1M LiCl +
0.7% H2O2 solutions under total immersion condition. The studies have shown that
3.5 % NaCl solution has not caused SCC damage, but a small addition of LiCl and
H2O2 in NaCl solution makes the media conducive to SCC. The peak aged temper has
shown the highest susceptibility to SCC, and the over aged temper the lowest.
Retrogression and reaging (RRA) treatments of the peak age temper have been found
to improve SCC resistance. Optical and SEM observations show that the initiation of
stress corrosion cracks has occurred from the base of the pits as well as from the sites
of intergranular corrosion, but the crack propagation path is invariably intergranular in
all the tempers of the alloy. The improved SCC resistance in the RRA and over aged
tempers has been attributed to the enhanced precipitation of anodic phases such as δ
and T1 at the sub-grain boundaries, high angle grain boundaries as well as within the
grains that increases uniform attack but minimizes the intensity of intergranular
Keywords: Al-Li alloy, Retrogression and reaging, Stress corrosion cracking
The attractive combination of lighter weight and higher stiffness of Al-Li alloys has
rendered them as candidate materials for aerospace applications. The use of Al-Li
alloys in place of the most widely used 7xxx series alloys will result in a saving of 8 10% structural weight along with an increase of 15% elastic modulus. Al-Li alloys
also have superior resistance to fatigue and creep crack growth and higher cryogenic
toughness . However, Al-Li alloys have some drawbacks such as the properties are
strongly sensitive to processing conditions, unattractive fracture behaviour, especially
poor ductility compared to the traditional high strength alloys, high anisotropy of
unrecrystallised products as well as susceptibility to environmental induced cracking
The literature review reveals that there are no consistent trends regarding the effect of
aging tempers on EIC of Al-base alloys [4,5]. For example, susceptibility to stress
corrosion cracking (SCC) is increased in the Al-Zn-Mg-Cu type alloys in the peak
aged (T8) tempers compared to the over aged (T7) tempers . Alloys based on AlLi-Cu-Zr and Al-Cu-Li-Zr systems are known to exhibit maximum resistance to SC
crack initiation in the near peak aged condition, whereas the magnesium containing
Al-Li-Cu-Mg-Zr alloys have exhibited maximum resistance to crack initiation in the
over aged condition [2,4].
Lumsden and Allen  have proposed film rupture and anodic dissolution, rather
than hydrogen embrittlement (HE), as the predominant mechanism for the SCC of
1441 alloy. They have reported that the alloy was equally susceptible in all aging
conditions. The susceptibility was also potential dependent and there existed a critical
potential near the pitting potential below which the alloy was resistant to SCC. They
suggested that the critical potential controlled crack propagation but not crack
initiation. Thakur and Balasubramaniam  have found that 1441 alloy is susceptible
to HE, suggesting that hydrogen may play an important role in SCC.
The weight saving and increased stiffness benefits of Al-Li alloys are useful to the
aerospace vehicle designers provided the resistance to SCC has been made to improve
by suitable heat treatments. The Al-Li-Cu-Mg-Zr alloys are susceptible to SCC in the
maximum strength peak aged tempers. The over aged temper has an acceptable SCC
resistance [2,4], but lower strength. A relatively new heat treatment process,
retrogression and reaging (RRA) treatment is a way to avoid this problem, which
makes the heat treatment very attractive to the aerospace industries [8,9].
Commercial retrogression heat treatments are identified by the T77 designation. RRA
is a two-stage heat treatment that combines the beneficial effects of both peak aged
and over aged tempers. RRA treatments produce microstructures that closely match
with those found in the SCC resistant T7 microstructures . Further, dislocations
developed during quenching from the solution treatment temperature are annealed out
during the retrogression treatment contributing to better SCC performance.
Retrogression and reaging (RRA) treatments have also been reported to improve the
HE resistance of 1441 alloy in all tempers .
The present work discusses the stress corrosion cracking behaviour of a 1441 Al-LiCu-Mg-Zr alloy in the peak aged, four retrogression and reaged, and over aged
tempers, studied by slow strain arte technique (SSRT) and constant load technique in
different SCC media. The SCC behaviour has been explained from the standpoint of
microstructural alterations upon RRA treatments.
2 Experimental Procedure
A 1441 (Russian counterpart to 8091 grade) alloy in the sheet form of approximate
thickness 2.0 mm has been used for SCC studies. The alloy was cast, homogenized,
hot rolled and cold rolled to required thickness. The heat treatment subjected to the
1441 Al-Li alloy was that the cold rolled sheets were solutionized at 530 - 535oC,
water quenched, stretched 1.5- 2.5 %, followed by artificial aging at 150oC for 4 hours
plus 1700C for 24 hours corresponding to peak aged (T8) temper. The chemical
composition (in wt. %) of the 1441 alloy is given in Table 1.
Table 1. Chemical Composition (wt. %) of the1441 Al-Li-Cu-Mg-Zr alloy.
Initially, retrogression, and retrogression and reaging (RRA) behaviour were studied
by hardness measurements. The retrogression treatment of the as–received T8 temper
1441 alloy was carried out at 230 and 2700C for different time periods varying from 1
to 40 minutes in a small vertical tube furnace in air. The temperature of the tube
furnace was maintained within +/- 20C. For SCC studies, the RRA schedule was
selected in such a way that (i) the retrogression time at a retrogression temperature
would cause maximum dissolution of the matrix strengthening δ' precipitates and (ii)
reaging the retrogressed state would result in the retention of strength properties in the
close proximity to that of the initial as-received peak aged strength. But, it is to be
borne in mind that the microstructures of the RRA tempers will definitely differ to
that of the as-received peak aged temper as the gross aging time in the RRA temper is
almost twice the aging time of the as-received T8 temper. The retrogression and
reaging schedule for the as-received specimens is shown schematically in Table 2.
Tensile specimens (transverse to the rolling direction) used for SCC studies were cut
from the as-received 1441alloy sheet. Specimen had the dimensions of 20 mm
extended gauge length, 4 mm width and 1.8 mm thickness. The surfaces of the gauge
portion of the tensile specimen were ground to 100 µm minimum so as to remove the
lithium and magnesium depleted and subsurface porosity zones, developed during
solutionizing carried out in air  and then the gauge portions were polished in
emery papers lubricated with kerosene oil up to 600 grits, and finally de-oiled by
rinsing in acetone
A CORTEST slow strain rate unit was used for testing at constant elongation rates in
air and in 3.5 % NaCl , 3.5% NaCl + 0.1M LiCl + 0.3 H2O2 and 3.5% NaCl + 0.1M
LiCl + 0.7 H2O2 solutions under total immersion condition. All the tests were
performed at room temperature at an initial strain rate of 5.5 X 10-6 s-1. Stress
corrosion cracking studies were also carried out by constant load method in these
media under total immersion condition using a Mayer’s SC unit, model MK-2, with a
lever ratio of 30:1.
Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) studies have been carried out on the peak
aged, over aged and some of the RRA tempers for assessing the microstructural
changes associated with RRA and aging time. For TEM studies, coupons of
approximate dimensions of 15 mm X 15 X 2 mm cut from 1441 sheet was
mechanically thinned to a thickness of approximately 100 µm, punched to get 3 mm
disc and finally thinned down to perforation using a Fischione twin-jet
electropolisher, operating at 25 volts and 2.5 amps, in an electrolyte of composition
30% HNO3 and 70% CH3COOH at a temperature of approximately –200C. A
PHILIPS CW12 TEM was used for the observation of microstructures. The stress
corrosion cracks were observed under optical microscope for ascertaining the crack
path and fractographic studies were carried out with a Jeol JSM-5800 scanning
electron microscope.. X-ray diffraction (XRD) study was carried out for the peak
aged, over aged and various retrogression and reaged tempers, using a Philips PW
1710 diffractometer unit with a cobalt target. Potentiodynamic polarization was
carried out by using a computer controlled Meinsberg PS6 potentiostat/galvanostat
with an inbuilt software.
Table 2: Rretrogression and reaging (RRA) schedule for the as-received T8 1441
At 215, 235, Isothermal reaging (IA) at
and 1700C for 26 corresponding to
270 C for 1 to peak aging temper.
Isothermal reaging (IA) at
1700C for 26 hours
At 2300C for Duplex aging (DA) at 1500C
for 36 hours, followed by
heating to 1900C at a rate of 5SCC, XRD,
7 0C/min and holding for 1
hour at the temperature
electrochemiIsothermal reaging (IA) at
1700C for 26 hours
At 270 C for Duplex aging (DA) at 1500C
for 36 hours, followed by
heating to 1900C at rate of 5-7
C/min and holding for 1 hour
at the temperature
3.1 Retrogression and Reaging (RRA) Behaviour
Fig. 1 shows the variation of hardness with retrogression time at retrogression
temperatures of 230 and 2700C and with retrogression plus reaging to the peak aging
temper. The graphs exhibit the characteristic behaviour of retrogression phenomenon.
The hardness versus retrogression time curves show two distinct regions. These is an
initial sharp decrease in hardness, attainment of a minimum, followed by a slight
increase in hardness after which no further change in hardness values for the
maximum retrogression time studied. The trends of the results are in consonance with
the results for 7xxx and 8xxx alloy series, obtained by other researchers [12,13].
Further, the curves show that the more the retrogression temperature the more is the
drop in hardness values, indicating greater dissolution of the matrix strengthening
3.2 Slow Strain Rate Tests (SSRT)
In the slow strain rate tests, the susceptibility to stress corrosion cracking (SCC) has
been characterized by various parameters viz. the plastic strain to fracture (εp), the
ductility ratio (DR) i.e. the ratio of plastic strain to fracture in environment to that in
air (εenvn/εair), and the fracture energy (FR) i.e. the area under the plastic region of the
stress strain curve in the environment.
and reaging to
and reaging to
a t 2 7 0 C,
at 2 3 0 C
H a r d n e s s, HV10
3 .5 % N a C l
3 .5 % N a C l + 0 .1 M L iC l + 0 .3 % H 2 O 2
3 .5 % N a C l + 0 .1 M L iC l + 0 .7 % H 2 O 2
S t r a in , %
F ig . 2 : R e p r e s e n t a t iv e s t r e s s s t r a in c u r v e s o f
1 4 4 1 R 2 3 0 D A te m p e r.
Fig. 1: Retrogression and reaging of 1441 - T8 Alloy
3.2.1 Effect of Environment on SCC damage
Fig. 2 shows representative stress strain curves of one (1441R230DA) of the RRA
tempers studied exhibiting different ductility values in air and in different SCC media.
The ductility is maximum in air and least in 3.5% NaCl + 0.1M LiCl + 0.7% H2O2
solution. Thus, according to the ductility parameter of indexing SCC susceptibility,
the stress strain curves indicate the relative severity of the environments causing SCC
damage. Among the test solutions, 3.5% NaCl is least damaging, whereas 3.5% NaCl
solution containing LiCl + H2O2 are more damaging. The SCC media have also
effected a reduction of tensile strength value. A similar effect has also been observed
in all the tempers. Table 3 gives the values of ductility ratio (DR) and fracture energy
values for all the tempers tested in all the different environments.
Table 3: Ductility ratio of the 1441 alloy of various tempers in different SCC
3.5% NaCl Solution
3.5% NaCl + 0.1M
3.5% NaCl + 0.1M
LiCl + 0.3% H2O2
LiCl + 0.7% H2O2
Fracture Ductility Fracture
energy, ratio (DR), energy, ratio (DR), energy,
εenvn / εair
εenvn / εair
εenvn / εair
3.2.2 Effect of RRA Treatment and Aging Time
The retrogressed and reaged tempers have shown higher ductility ratio and fracture
energy values indicating better resistance to SCC than the conventional peak aged
temper (Table 3).
The average values of plastic strain to fracture (εp, %) for all the tempers, tested in all
the environments, are shown as bar diagram in Fig. 3. The diagram gives an overall
view of the severity of the environment to SCC attack and also the effect of different
tempers. For a given environment, the over aged temper has the maximum resistance
to SCC, whereas the conventional peak aged temper is most susceptible to SCC. The
resistance to SCC attack of the retrogressed and reaged tempers lies in between that of
the conventional peak aged and over aged tempers. The bar diagram also indicates
that the environments containing LiCl + H2O2 are damaging to, whereas the 3.5%
NaCl solution has little damaging effect.
3.5 % NaCl
3.5 % NaCl + 0.1M LiCl + 0.3 % H 2O 2
3.5 % NaCl + 0.1M LiCl + 0.7 % H 2O 2
P l a s t i c s t r a i n t o f r a c t u r e, %
R270IA R270DA R230IA R230DA T7
Fig. 3: Plastic strain to fracture of (a) 1441 alloys of
various tempers tested in different environments
at an initial strian rate of 5.5 X 10 s .
3.3 Constant Load Test
Constant load tests have been carried out to assess the SCC susceptibility of 1441
alloy in the peak aged, retrogression and isothermal and duplex aged, and over aged
tempers in 3.5% NaCl + 0.1M LiCl + 0.3% H2O2 and in 3.5 NaCl + 0.1M LiCl +
0.7% H2O2 solutions at a stress level of 0.92-0.94 of yield stress of the alloy. The test
results are shown in Table 4, with time to fracture (tf) as the SCC susceptibility index.
The time to fracture in all the retrogressed and reaged tempers is more than the time to
fracture in the peak aged tempers in both the environments. Thus, the constant load
results also indicate an improvement of SCC resistance on retrogression and reaging
(RRA) treatments. Further, it is to be mentioned that constant load SCC tests in 3.5%
NaCl solution have not caused failure in the 1441 alloy in all tempers, indicating that
the solution without any addition of LiCl and H2O2 under constant immersion
condition is not conducive to SCC.
Table 4: Constant load SCC results of 1441 alloy of various tempers.
Time of failure (Tf), h
3.5 % NaCl + 0.1M + LiCl +
0.3 % H2O2 solution
3.5 % NaCl + 0.1M + LiCl + 0.7
% H2O2 solution
30, 120, 110
: No Failure.
3.4 Mode of Cracking
Stress corrosion (SC) cracking morphology was examined using SEM and optical
microscope. Fig. 4(a-f) shows a few representatives SC cracks of 1441 alloy of
various tempers tested by SSRT and constant load method in different media. The
sources of crack initiation are various. Cracks have initiated either from the pits or
from the slip emergence step, or from the intergranularly corroded regions (Fig. 4a).
But observations at higher magnification reveal that the crack propagation paths are
invariably intergranual and sub-intergranular (Fig 4b, 4c and 4d). The pits are larger
in size (Fig. 4e and 4f) and intergranular attack is more in the samples tested by
constant load method than those in the samples tested by SSRT. This is due to the fact
that in constant load test, samples are exposed for longer time than those tested by
SSRT. Further, Fig. 4f shows that the pit base is blunted in the over age temper. This
might be the reason for the better SCC resistance of the over aged temper. In samples
tested in 3.5 % NaCl solution, numerous pits are visible, but there is no evidence of
crack initiation at their base. In retrogressed and reaged and over aged tempers, the
sources of crack initiation sites and crack propagation path are the same as those in
the peak aged tempers.
3.5 XRD Studies
Fig. 5 shows X-ray diffractograms of peak aged (T8), RRA isothermal (1441R230IA)
and duplex aged (1441R270DA), and over aged (T7) tempers using cobalt target. The
diffractograms of all the tempers of the alloys show peaks of all the probable phases,
such as α-Al matrix, δ′ (Al3Li), δ (AlLi), S′ (Al2CuMg), T1 (Al2CuLi) and β′ (Al3Zr)
phases, that would be present in the alloy system. The diffractograms of the samples
of the RRA tempers, exhibit the appearance of additional T1(102) peak and other
intensified peaks of the T1 and δ phases.
The appearance of additional T1(102) peak and other intensified peaks of the T1 and δ
phases is due to fact that during retrogression, δ′ (Al3Li) phase dissolves into solution
Fig. 4(a-f): Stress corrosion cracks of (a-b) 1441- T8 temper showing cracks from the
base of the pit as well as from other site, but the cracking is intergranular. Crack
propagation paths are also intergranular and sub-intergranular in (c) 1441R230IA and
(d) 1441770DA retrogressed and reaged tempers. (e) Pits sizes are larger under
constant load test and (e) Pit is blunted in the 1441-T7 over aged temper. The SCC
media is 3.5% NaCl containing LiCl and H2O2.
resulting in an increase of lithium content. This increased lithium content causes
nucleation and growth of lithium-bearing phases such as T1 and δ as well as the
growth of the phases that exist in the T8 temper alloy. Hence, in the RRA tempers
there are additional or intensified peaks of these phases.
β (114) δ
Fig. 5: X-ray diffractograms of the 1441 alloy of various tempers using cobalt target.
3.6 TEM Studies
Some of the representative TEM photomicrographs of the alloy in its various tempers
are given in Fig. 6(a-f). Fig. 6a, the bright field image, exhibits grains and grain
boundaries containing β' dispersoids, and homogeneously precipitated uniform
distribution of fine T1 and S' phases. In one of the grains in the micrographs, the
preferential heterogeneous precipitation of these phases on the dislocations can be
seen. Equilibrium δ phase is also visible on the high angle grain boundaries.
Fig. 6(b-c) shows TEM photomicrographs of the retrogressed and duplex reaged
(1441R230DA) tempers. Fig. 6b shows clearly the uniform homogeneous distribution
of S' phase. Fig. 6c shows the equilibrium δ phase at the high angle grain boundaries
and at higher magnification (Fig 6d) these equilibrium δ phase is also visible at the
Fig. 6(e-f), the TEM micrograph of the 1441-T7 temper shows equilibrium δ
precipitates on the high angle grain boundaries, homogeneous uniform distribution of
T1 and S' phases as well as heterogeneous precipitation of these phase along the
dislocations . The δ precipitates in this micrograph for the over aged temper are
quite larger in size compared to δ precipitates visible in TEM micrographs of
the1441-T8 temper (Fig. 6a). The large size of the precipitates on the grain boundaries
is expected in the over aged temper. The more the aging time the more is the
nucleation and growth of this phase on the grain boundaries. The total aging time in
the T7 temper is about four times to that of the T8 temper. Fig. 8f exhibits the densely
formed T1 precipitates and S' phase on the matrix . The dense population of T1
precipitates on the matrix dictates the condition that over age temper should have very
good resistance to SCC for this precipitation hardening aluminium alloy.
3.7 Electrochemical Polarization Studies
Potentiodynamic polarization was carried out for assessing the effect of aging time
and retrogression and reaging treatments on the electrochemical behaviour of the 1441
alloy of various tempers. The trends of variation of electrochemical parameters with
aging are in consistent with the results of other investigators [4, 16, 17]. Fig. 7 shows
the potentiodynamic polarization curves of 1441 alloy in the peak aged, retrogression
and reaged, isothermal and duplex, and over aged tempers in 3.5 % NaCl. The shape
of the polarization curves is similar for all the tempers. The curves show that the open
circuit potential (OCP) has shifted towards more negative values
Fig. 6(a-f): TEM photomicrographs of the 1441 alloy. (a) 1441T8 temper homogeneous
distribution of T1, S' and β' precipitates in the matrix, and heterogeneous precipitation of
T1 and S' on the dislocations. In 1441R230DA temper (b) uniform and widespread
distribution of S' within the matrix, (c) equilibrium δ phase along the high angle grain
boundary as well as (d) along the sub-grain boundaries. In 1441-T7 over aged temper
(e) exhibiting larger size δ phase along the grain boundary, distribution of T1, and S'
precipitates in the matrix, and heterogeneously on the dislocations and (f) T1, and S'
precipitates densely within the matrix.
with increasing aging time and RRA treatment. The OCP of the over aged temper has
the most negative value, whereas the OCP values of the retrogressed and reaged
tempers lie in between the OCP values of the over aged and peak aged tempers. It is
an established fact that the OCP depends, for a given environment, on the
microstructure and the constituent phases. Thus, based on the OCP values, it can be
inferred that the microstructure of the retrogression and reaged tempers approaches
the microstructure of the over aged temper. The shifting of the potentials towards
anodic direction (i.e. more negative values) with the RRA and aging time can be
attributed to the presence of higher amounts of anodic phases such as T1, δ and S',
which has also been confirmed by XRD and TEM studies.
The initial decrease of hardness with retrogression time (Fig. 1) is due to the
preferential dissolution of the shearable coherent matrix strengthening δ' (Al3Li)
precipitates which are no longer stable at the retrogression temperature. Decrease of
hardness values on retrogression is also due to the decrease of dislocation density. The
minimum in the retrogression curve is indicative of the maximum dissolution of the δ'
precipitates. Thereafter, the rate of dissolution and the rate of reprecipitation of the δ'
Current density, mA/Cm
1 4 4 1 -T 8
1 4 4 1 R 2 7 0 IA
1441R 270D A
1 4 4 1 R 2 3 0 IA
1441R 230D A
1 4 4 1 -T 7
0 .0 1
1 E -3
1 E -4
1 E -5
-9 0 0
-8 5 0
-8 0 0
-7 5 0
-7 0 0
-6 5 0
-6 0 0
-5 5 0
-5 0 0
-4 5 0
P o te n tia ls , m V ( S C E )
F ig .7 : P o te n tid y n a m ic p o la r is a tio n c u r v e s o f 1 4 4 1 a llo y
o f v a r io u s te m p e r s in 3 .5 % N a C l s o lu tio n .
precipitates might be occurring at the same rate and therefore the hardness remains
more or less the same with retrogression time. The decrease of hardness and strength
values with increase of retrogression temperatures can be attributed to the fact that
higher retrogression temperature causes greater dissolution of the δ' precipitates.
Reaging the retrogressed tempers causes reprecipitation of the matrix strengthening δ'
precipitates resulting in an increase of hardness and strength values. The curves
indicate that reaging of the samples retrogressed for a short period has led to the
regaining of the original peak hardness values. But, with higher retrogression
temperature and time, original peak aged hardness values have not been attained on
reaging. This is due to the fact that the higher retrogression time leads to a state of
over aging temper  and that the retrogression temperature is higher than the peak
The SCC susceptibility has been found to be low for the alloys in all the tempers
under constant immersion condition in 3.5% NaCl solution. The SSRT and constant
load methods of SCC testing results show that the addition of small amounts of LiCl
and H2O2 in 3.5% NaCl solution has made the media conducive to SCC in both the
alloys. The absence of SCC in constant immersion condition in NaCl solution has
been reported by other investigators as well [2, 19, 20, 21]. The low SCC
susceptibility in NaCl solution has been attributed to the depassivating nature of the
solution promoting relatively large and blunted pits and blunt grain boundary and
subgrain boundary fissures.
The addition of LiCl and H2O2 to the 3.5% NaCl solution brings the alloy
environment system into a condition of borderline passivity, which is a wellestablished potential state for SCC in many ferrous alloy systems. The importance of
passivation in promoting SCC in aluminium alloys has also been established through
the work of many authors. Braun  has also reported that a certain amount of
lithium ions dissolved during immersions seemed to be required to promote SCC.
Buchheit et el  has reported that in the 2090 alloy the atmospheric CO2 absorbed
into the crevice solution creates a CO32- - Cl- solution of gradually decreasing pH
which allows passivation of the crack walls by the precipitation of LiAlO2. Moran et
el  and Craig et el  have found that either atmospheric CO2 or the addition of
LiCO3 to a NaCl solution promoted SCC of the 2090 alloy. They have established that
the precipitation of a salt layer of LiALO2 inside a pit promotes the formation of a
sharp fissure with a small, localized anodic area, which is necessary for the nucleation
of a stress corrosion crack. Passivation also inhibits crack wall dissolution,
maintaining a sharp propagating crack.
The stress-assisted rupture of the passive film normally leads to the local dissolution
of the exposed area as it acts as a small anode in contact with a large cathode i.e. the
film surface. In the present alloy system, the film rupture exposes an area containing
electrochemically anodic T1 and δ precipitates and it is more likely that the local cell
formation leads to a preferential dissolution of these precipitates. The nucleation of
crack is produced by pit formation inside which the solution pH goes down the level
of 3-4 [2, 24], thus facilitating hydrogen ion reduction as the principal cathodic
reaction. It has also been reported  that Cu-rich zones act as cathodic depolariser
for hydrogen ion reduction, since the hydrogen exchange current density on copper is
three times of magnitude higher than that of aluminium. This enhances the anodic
current density leading to rapid dissolution. In our studies, the majority of the cracks
have been observed to emerge from the base of pits, which could be deemed to have
formed at the sites of film breakdown. The lateral growth of the pits has been a later
stage development with the intergranular corrosion of the adjacent areas contributing
to this growth.
Optical and SEM observations have indicated that stress corrosion cracks have also
originated at sites other than the base of pits, such as the regions of intergranular
corrosion. The T1 and δ precipitates are anodic to the matrix [26, 27]. Therefore, there
are a lot of microscopic galvanic cells, each consisting of a large cathode and a small
anode. The small anode/cathode area ratio results in a high anodic current density,
which provides a large driving force for the dissolution of these phases. Thus, the
intergranularly dissolved regions would act as sites for crack initiation in the presence
of monotonically increasing stress. Further, the crack initiation is assisted by the
propensity for coarse planar slip generated due to the coherent δ' precipitates which
causes stress concentration at the grain boundaries.
In the propagation stage, there is a build up of metallic ions at the crack tip, which
hydrolyze, resulting in a local acidic condition. This acidic solution inside a crack and
the lower potential at the crack tip, as a result of local cell action, increase the H3O+
reduction rate to either H2 gas and/or atomic hydrogen . Accelerated rapid
dissolution due to cathodic depolarization may be prevalent in the propagation stage
also. At the same time, hydrogen induced cracking may also be operative. However, a
visible evolution of gas, presumably H2, during the test was observed. This is an
indication of the difficulty of entry of hydrogen atoms into the metal, apparently due
to the restricted reduction of H3O+ at the passivated crack walls overlaid with LiAlO2
or LiCO3. . So, localized anodic dissolution can be envisaged as the dominating
mechanism during the propagation stage as against a hydrogen induced crack
propagation, as suggested by Balasubramanian et el  as the dominating
mechanism in the SCC of an Al-Li-Cu alloy in 0.5 M NaCl. The difference in
operating conditions and alloy chemistry could be the reason for such a difference.
The improvement of SCC resistance in the RRA tempers could be the result of delay
in crack initiation and higher resistance of crack propagation compared to that in the
peak aged temper. This can largely be attributed to the microstructural changes
associated with RRA heat treatment mainly in regard to the size and distribution of
the anodic phases δ (AlLi) and T1 (Al2CuLi) precipitated within the grains, along the
subgrain and grain boundaries as well as of the S' phase.
Retrogression and reaging (RRA) treatments result in the formation of additional
equilibrium δ (AlLi) and T1 phases as indicated by an additional peak of T1 phase
and/or more intense peaks of T1 and δ phases (Fig. 5, X-ray diffractograms). TEM
photomicrographs also exhibit uniform homogeneous distribution of S and T1
precipitates (Fig. 6b) as well δ phase along the grain boundaries and sub-grain
boundaries (fig. 6c and Fig 6d). The higher OCP values observed in potentiodynamic
polarization studies (Fig.7) in the RRA tempers compared to those in the peak aged
tempers also suggest that RRA treatments have resulted in the precipitation of the
anodic S', T1 and δ phases. The initiation of stress corrosion cracks in this alloy in T8
temper, as already mentioned, is by preferential dissolution of grain boundary δ and
T1 precipitates, due to their anodic nature with respect to the matrix, resulting in the
formation of galvanic cells. In the retrogressed and reaged and in the duplex aging
tempers, uniform homogeneous distribution of S and T1 precipitates and more of
δ phase along the grain boundaries as well as along the sub-grain boundaries reduce
the potential difference for the formation of galvanic cells between the grain and the
matrix. Therefore, the tendency of uniform corrosion is more, whereas the propensity
of intergranular dissolution is largely reduced. Also in RRA tempers, the
homogeneous distribution of S' phase throughout the matrix (Fig. 6b) improves slip
homogenization (i.e. minimization of strain localization) by promoting cross-slip, and
the low dislocation density [7,10] causes a reduction in stress concentration. All these
factors contribute to the improved SCC resistance of the alloys in the RRA tempers.
Further, the greater resistance to SCC can also be an outcome of a greater resistance
to stable pit formation. The RRA treatments have resulted in the shifting of the OCP
values towards the anodic side. The potential difference between OCP and pitting
potential in the RRA and over aged tempers is less compared to that in the peak age
tempers, thus reducing the tendency to pit formation.
In the over aged (T7) temper, the aging time is much longer compared to the peak
aged and retrogressed and reaged temper. The more the aging time, the more is the
precipitation of δ and T1 phases, on the grain boundaries and on the sub-grain
boundaries, which is clearly exhibited in the TEM photomicrographs (Fig. 6e and Fig
6f). Thus, the potential difference of the galvanic cells formed between the grain and
grain boundaries will be small leading to more uniform attack and with low
propensity of intergranular corrosion. This in combination with lower strength results
in an improved SCC resistance in the T7 temper.
1.XRD and TEM studies on the 1441 alloy of various tempers have revealed the
presence of all the probable phases, δ′, δ, S′, T1 and β′ (Al3Zr) that would be present in
the alloy system. Further, XRD studies have exhibited an additional peak and/ or
intense peaks of T1 and δ phases in the RRA tempers. TEM studies have also
confirmed the presence of higher amounts of the anodic δ precipitates along the grain
boundaries as well as along the sub-grain boundaries and wide spread uniform
distribution of Τ1 and S′ precipitates.
2.Electrochemical polarization studies have shown that the OCP values of the RRA
tempers (T77) lie in between those of the T8 and T7 tempers indicating the presence
of higher amounts of these anodic phases in the RRA microstructures.
3.Retrogression treatments given to the 1441-T8 alloy cause a decrease in hardness.
Reaging of the lower temperature and short duration retrogressed tempers leads to the
regaining of the original T8 hardness.
4.SSRT and constant load methods of SCC testing show that 3.5% NaCl solution is
not conducive to SCC susceptibility due to its strong depassivating nature. The
addition of a small amount of LiCl and H2O2 in 3.5% NaCl, makes the media
conducive to SCC in the 1441 alloy by maintaining a condition of passivasion
required for SCC.
5.The T7 temper has the maximum SSC resistance whereas the T8 has the least SCC
resistance. The resistance of RRA tempers lies in between the SCC resistance of the
T8 and T7 tempers.
6. Local anodic dissolution plays the dominant role in SCC in this alloy. The higher
SCC resistance of the RRA and T7 tempers is attributed to the decreased galvanic
effect caused by a uniform distribution of T1 and δ precipitates within the matrix, and
additional precipitation of these precipitates on the grain boundaries as well as on the
J. R. Davis, Davis & Associates, (1998). ASM Specialty Handbook,
Aluminium - lithium alloys. ASM, Int. Mat. Inf. Society, Ohio, USA.
N. J. H. Holroyd, A. Gray, G. M. Scamans and R. Herman (1986).
Environment - Sensitive Fracture of Al-Li-Cu-Mg Alloys. Proc. of the 3rd Int.
Conf. on Aluminium-Lithium Alloys III, The Inst. Metals, London, 310-320.
A. Conde, J. J. De Damaborenea (1999). Stress Corrosion Cracking Behaviour
of 8090 Al-Li Alloy at 313K. The Effect of Grain Structure (1999). Corrosion
Science, 41, 1079 – 1088.
A. Gray (1987). Factors Influence the Environmental Behaviour of Aluminium
– Lithium Alloys. Proc of the 4th Int. Conf. on Aluminium-Lithium, Journal
de Physique Colloque C3, supplement au no 9, Tome, 48, september, Paris,
C3-891 – C3 904.
M. O. Speidel (1975). Metallurgical Trans A, 6A, 631.
J. B. Lumsden and A. T. Allen (1988). The Stress Corrosion cracking
Behaviour of AlLi Alloy 8090. Corrsion Sci., 44, 527 – 532.
C. Thakur and R. Balasubramaniam (1997). Hydrogen Embrittlement of Aged
and Retrogressed – reaged Al-Li-Cu-Mg alloys. Acta mater., 45, 1323 - 1132.
B. M. Cina and B. Rarish (1974). Aluminium Industrial Products, ASM,
B. M. Cina (1974.). U. S. Patent 3,856,584, December 24, 1974.
K. S. Ghosh, K. Das and U. K. Chatterjee (2003). Studies on Microstuctural
Changes Upon on Retrogression and Reaging Treatment to 8090 Al-Li-CuMg-Zr Alloy. To be communicated.
S. Fox, H. M. Flower and D. S. McDarmaid (1986). Formation of Solutedepleted Surfaces in Al-Li-Cu-Mg-Zr Alloys and Their Influences on
Mechanical Properties. Proc. of the 3rd Int. Conf. on Aluminium-Lithium Alloys
III, The Inst. Metals, London, 263 – 272.
J. K. Park (1988). Influence of Retrogression and Reaging on the Strength and
Stress Corrosion Resistance of Aluminium Alloy 7075 – T6. Mater. Sci.
Engg., A103, 223 - 231.
Matthew B. Hall and John W. Martin (1994). The effect of Retrogression
Temperature on the properties of an RRA (Retrogressed and Reaged) 7150
Aluminium Alloy. Z. Metallkd, 85, 134 - 139.
S. Abis, E. Evangelista, P. Mengucci and G. Riontino (1989). Microstructural
Evaluation of Al-Li-Cu-Mg-Zr Alloy During Ageing at 1600C. Proc. of the 5th
Int. Conf. on Aluminium- Lithium Alloys, 681 – 690.
Bi-Ping Huang and Zi-Qiao Zheng (1998). Effects of Li Content on
Precipitation in Al-Cu-(Li)–Mg-Ag-Zr Alloys. Scripta Materialia, 38, 357 362.
Reboul and P. Meyer (1987). Intergranular and Exfoliation Corrosion Study of
Al-Li-Cu-Mg-Zr Alloys. Proc of the 4th Int. Conf. on Aluminium-Lithium,
Journal de Physique Colloque C3, supplement au no 9, Tome, 48, september,
Paris, C3 881 – C3 889.
B. Bavarian, J. Becker, S. N. Parikh and M. Zamanzadeh (1989). Localised
Corrosion of 2090 and 2091 Al-Li alloys. Proc. of the 5th Int. Conf. on
Aluminium- Lithium Alloys V, 1227 – 1236.
V. Komisarov, M. Talianker and B. Cina (1996). The Effect of Retrogression
and Reaging on the Resistance to Stress Corrosion of an 8090 Type
Aluminium Alloy. Materials Science and Engg, A221, 113 – 121.
J. G. Craig, R. C. Newman, M. R. Jarrett and N. J. H. Holroyd (1987). Local
Chemistry of Stress Corrosion Cracking in Al-Li-Cu-Mg Alloys. Proc. of the
4th Int. Conf. on Aluminium – Lithium, C3- 825 – C3 833.
G. Disson, M. Reboul, and C. Giaud (1989). A Stress Corrosion Cracking
Study of the 2091 Al-Li Alloy. Proc. of the 5th Int. Conf. on Aluminium –
Lithium, 1261 – 1269.
James P. Moron and Glenn E. Stoner (1989). Solution Chemistry Effects on
the Stress Corrosion Cracking Behaviour of Alloy 2090 (Al-Li-Cu) and Alloy
2024 (Al-Cu-Mg). Proc. of the 5th Int. Conf. on Aluminium – Lithium, 1187 –
R. Braun (1995). Evaluation of the Stress Corrosion Cracking Behaviour of
Damage Tolerant Al-Li Sheet using the Slow Strain Rate Testing Technique.
Mater. Sci. Engg., A190, 143 – 154.
R. G. Buchheit, F. D Wall, G. E. Stoner and J. P Moran (1995). Anodic
Dissolution Based Mechanism for the Rapid Cracking, Pre-exposure
Phenomenon Demonstrated by Aluminium – Lithium – Copper Alloys.
Corrosion Science, 51, 417 - 428.
R. G. Buchheit and G. E. Stoner (1989). The Corrosion Behaviour of the T1
(Al2CuLi) Intermetallic Compound in Aqueous Environment. Proc. of the 5th
Int. Conf on Aluminium-Lithium, 1347 - 1356.
E I Meletis (1992). Parkins Symp. on Fundamental of Stress Corrosion
Cracking ( Eds. S. M. Bruemmer, E. I. Meletis, R. H. Jones, W. W. Garberich,
F. P. Ford and R. H. Staehle, TMS Publication, 353.
P. Niskanen, T. H. Sanders Jr. and J. G. Rinker (1982). Corrosion Science, 22,
J. M Sater and T H Sanders (1989). Corrosion Behaviour of Binary Al-Li and
Ternary Al-Li-Zr Alloys. Proc. of the 5th Int. Conf. on Aluminium- Lithium
Alloys, 1217 - 1225
C. B. Bargeron, R. C. Benson (1980). Analysis of the gases evolved during the
pitting corrosion of aluminium in various electrolytes. J. Electrochem. Soc,
T. D. Burieigh (1991). Corrosion, 47, 89..
R. Balasubramanium and D. J. Duquette (1992). Parkins Symp. on
Fundamental of Stress Corrosion Cracking, 131.